Why do so many cars travel to Ukraine during the war? Analysis

fakenews.pl 2 years ago

The war in Ukraine is inactive the dominant subject in the media space. Narrations designed to make resentment or doubts about refugees in Poland are inactive popular on social media. 1 specified example is the movie from TikTok, where the author asks any suggestive questions about this issue. Many of the issues raised are very popular on social media and have been raised many times. So we decided to look at them and examine them in a series of short articles.

Our evaluation:

Analysis

More about our evaluation system:

The movie appeared a fewer days ago on the TikTok platform. It comes from a canal dagajarock, The subject is astrology or magic. Subject substance Ukraine it was barely discussed on it. However, the author decided to evidence movie on this issue, which had quite a few interest. No circumstantial questions were presented in the video either, but any suggestive questions were raised. This is simply a popular rhetorical technique, which theoretically makes it impossible for the author to dismiss a circumstantial agenda, due to the fact that it “only asks questions”. However, as she admits at the end of the film: “No Ukrainian will be my brother.” The movie in a large part is besides based on anecdotal evidence, and the claims there have no circumstantial source.

In this text, we will address the first question in this video: “Why are cars being exported from Poland on specified a scale to a country under war?” specified a question is intended to rise doubts for the recipient and undermine the strength of the conflict. Indirectly, it besides suggests that war may even be profitable for Ukraine. specified narratives have been presented for a long time (Here. For example), therefore, claims specified as those on the movie should not be underestimated. They form part of wider disinformation and propaganda content. Of course, they are without foundation and economical situation Ukraine is Very severe. The answer to the question asked in the movie is comparatively simple and besides prosaic and involves reasonably apparent marketplace mechanisms.

Elimination of the duty

Reason why import cars to Ukraine during the war increased rapidly, was temporary abolishing duties, excise duties and VAT utilized cars by the local authorities. The intent of this provision was to make up for the losses caused by the war in the armed forces car park and civilian users. The above mentioned fees may Up to 30% of the value of the imported car. It is so hard to wonder that during this period cars were being brought in massively, even during the armed conflict.

For the first 2 months of invasion destroyed About 220,000 vehicles. The provision on the abolition of fees entered into force in early April 2022. It has brought a very sharp increase in imports of second-hand cars. In March 2022 brought Only 2,000 cars. However, more than 90 1000 vehicles utilized went to Ukraine between 9 April and 19 May this year. Fees have been Restored by the Ukrainian authorities on 1 July 2022. This caused discontent and protests, including border crossing point in Zosina. The consequence was predictable, 7-fold decrease import of utilized cars. From April to late June brought to Ukraine over 202 1000 utilized vehicles.

Imports from Poland

Many imported cars came from Poland. As estimated In the first half of the year, it was 36.9% of all utilized cars downloaded to Ukraine (from which imports were repeatedly lower from January to March than after). The first 3 cars from Poland included the following models: Volkswagen Passat, Volkswagen Golf and Skoda Octavia. Among the models in the top 15, the average price exceeding PLN 20 000 afraid only 1 model (Audi A6). By specialists from Samar Institute for Automotive marketplace investigation the following factors impacted specified large imports of cars from Poland:

(...) favourable geographical location: transportation of cars to Ukraine is easier and cheaper; rather a large selection of utilized cars in an affordable price category; the number of sales notices for individual models – especially diesel – which can be even greater than in Germany.

Attention was besides paid to the smaller language barrier between Poles and Ukrainians, which may be a problem in dealing with Western salesmen. Moreover, bureaucratic procedures are not complicated and buying does not take long. So there is nothing amazing about the fact that people in our country were willing to sale cars at good prices, and could avoid a long-term search for a buyer. The Ukrainians, on the another hand, could import cars comparatively cheaply and easily. For both parties, the situation was simply favorable. So there is no mysterious mechanics behind the full process, but a simple marketplace calculation that even works despite the ongoing war.

Military cars

In addition to bringing in utilized cars for sale, any of them were passed on, usually for free, to Ukrainian armed forces. However, we do not know circumstantial statistics. For apparent reasons, there were field cars, especially pick-ups. In Poland, many institutions as well as private individuals organized collections and carried vehicles across the east border. They are very desirable by soldiers on the front, due to the fact that they can be utilized for reconnaissance, fast transport of tiny troops or fast evacuation of wounded. Theirs. The service life is short. . . . . . . . . . 22 specified cars passed Polish foresters, for example. Privates besides take specified measures, they are both Ukrainians mixing in Poland as well as Poles themselves. Among them is simply a writer and reporter Jacek Hugo-Bader is Mateusz Wodziński, more commonly known as Exen. However, there are quite a few activities to get off-road cars for Ukraine, and there are dozens of rebounds on the Internet.

Summary

Among the manipulation techniques designed to make disagreements between Ukrainians and Poles are besides the little apparent ones. 1 of them is asking seemingly innocent questions, which in fact aim to rise doubts and uncertainty about the subject. A good example of specified manipulation is the TikToka movie discussed. Contrary to suggestions, mass import of cars from Poland applies only to second-hand vehicles. Additionally, it continued in a specified time window erstwhile Ukrainian authorities abolished car import charges. However, the losses in our east neighbor's car park are very advanced and it can take years to catch up. any of the second-hand vehicles imported into Ukraine are intended for armed forces.

Sources

Samar Automotive marketplace investigation Institute:

Republic of: https://www.rp.pl/economy/art37032071-war-in-Ukraine-preliminary-cost-rebuilding-destruction

Auto World: https://www.auto-swiat.pl/news/updates/Ukrainian-exports-from-Polish-passaty-without-cla-lista-out-cars-to-Ukraine/sfgpg8k#slaid-1 and https://www.auto-sworld.pl/news/updates/jack-hugo-bader-organises-cars-for-soldiers-in-Ukraine-talk/11pymw5

Infor: https://mojafirma.infor.pl/moto/news/market/5470033,Export-auta-na-Ukraine.html

TVN24: https://tvn24.pl/polska/zosin-ukrainscy-drivers-locked-drog-to-cross-border-straight-border-drivers-dissatisfied-with-return-customs-and-tax-vat-5772705

Moto Focus: https://motofocus.pl/brands-cars/104999/ile-used-aut-from-Polish-trad-on-ukraine-ten-trend-strel-juz-stopped

Radio Lublin: https://radio.lublin.pl/2022/05/Polish-foresters-support-ukraine-cars-terranean were handed over/

Gazeta Wrocławska: https://gazetawrocławska.pl/wroclawian-introductory-cars-and-terranean-from-europa-west-and-send-je-on-Ukraine-see-je-on-sands/ar/c1-16115127

Spider’s Web: https://spidersweb.pl/2022/08/polak-helps-ukrainie-passport.html

Read Entire Article