Valve issued a uncommon public consequence to fresh York's lawyer General Letitia James's suit regarding loot boxes at Counter-Strike 2, Dota 2 and squad Fortress 2, arguing that this mechanics is not illegal gambling under fresh York State law. The company claims that objects are cosmetic, optional and comparable to physical trade packages, while paying attention to its efforts to reduce 3rd organization gambling and informing that striving to make objects non-transferable would harm consumers.