Who blocks Agnieszka Dziemianowicz-Bąk? The weaknesses of the Ministry of Labour and Conflict on the Left

In the program "From the political bottom" by Piotr Szumlewicz and Piotr Nowak, the bitter diagnosis sounds: Agnieszka Dziemianowicz-Bąk, although active and ambitious, was stuck between the deficiency of political background, opposition of coalitionists and her own mistakes. Its ministry produces projects that do not have a chance to implement, and the left-wing agenda melts into populist gestures and PR rituals. Is this an individual crisis or a full formation?

Left-wing minister without left-wing force

In the conversation of both publicists, there is simply a joint conclusion: Dziemianovich-Bąk has no real political power. Her projects — from reducing garbage contracts to shortening the week of work — are rejected by successive ministries, and coalitions see no reason to support them.

Nowak notes that although Włodzimierz Czarzasty boasts about "perfect relations" with Donald Tuski, this does not translate into the negotiating power of the left. The minister is left alone and its ministry, as the leader says, “behaving like opposition in his own government.”

Good ideas, mediocre effectiveness

Szmulewicz admits that part of the ministry's activities were needed:

• an increase in the death allowance,
• the proposal to include civilian law contracts in traineeships,
• limitation of free traineeships.

The problem is that most of these projects either got stuck or divorced. The pilotage of the shorter week of work took only a fewer twelve companies, and the Act on the conversion of garbage trucks into jobs was shot by another resorts.

Population alternatively of social democracy?

The strongest criticism concerns the ideological direction. Szumlewicz points out that the flagship projects of the Ministry — widow’s pension, “active parent”, free Christmas Eve — have nothing to do with modern social democracy.

It is alternatively a continuation of the logic of the Law and Justice: cash services, conservative gestures, no investment in public services.

"This is simply a policy that strengthens matrimony at the expense of singles and informal unions. It's not left-wing, it's rudely familistic," Shumlewicz emphasises.

PR alternatively of politics

Both commentators pay attention to the infantile kind of communication of the minister: videos, dumplings, smiles, lifestyle Instagram.

"It's self-puppie. A labour marketplace politician should not play the function of a smiling dumpling aunt," says Nowak.

Biggest loss: wage in the budget

In the second part of the Shumlewicz programme, the minister agreed to a evidence low increase in minimum and budget wages — only 3%.

This means a real fall in wages in the public sector and further weakening of the state.

“This is simply a disaster. The Minister of Labour is firming a decision that hits the poorest," he concludes.

Did Dziemianovich-Bąk miss her chance?

Nowak recalls that she could run for presidential election, but she resigned due to the fact that Tusk demanded that the ministry be given up.

"Maybe she should have taken a chance. present her position is weaker than ever," she says.

Left without rudder

A broader image emerges from the conversation: the crisis does not concern just 1 minister but the full formation.

No courage, no strategy, no negotiating ability.

"The Black 1 subjugated the party, and the remainder of the leaders were frightened of taking off against it. It's a show of weakness," says Shumlewicz.

Civic Reset

No compromises, no censorship. Created both by journalists and audiences, due to the fact that civic media must be interactive. We're storming the 4th wall between reporters and recipients.

Patronite.plPublications