How large is the Polish economy? Version 2.0 (final)

niepoprawni.pl 11 hours ago

What was Poland's GDP if it did not subtract indirect consumption?

In the authoritative accounts of ESA 2010 - GDP=Global production (Output) minus Indirect consumption of net taxes on products.

If “we do not subtract indirect consumption”, it is the Output + taxes itself – in practice this concept is very akin to the Anglo-Saxon Gross Output (GO).

How much is that today?

What is it present (current prices, million PLN)? Global production of 2024 is 7 356 414,000, taxes are 404 122,000,000, or 7 760 536,000. (Tables 1 to 2 "Product Account" and "Global Production" of the GUS Quarterly Accounts of GDP 2020-2024). Data for 2024 are preliminary, announced in April 2025. Output + taxes (we do not subtract IC) is 213% of GDP.

This means that on average 53 gr from each gold production goes to intermediate consumption and 47 gr creates added value.

In global dollars (PPP):

The purchasing power base 2024 (World Bank): 1 Int $ ≤ PLN 2.10.

PLN 7 760 billion ÷ 2.10 billion Int $ 3.7 billion.

What does this indicator tell us?

It is more "inflated" than GDP due to the fact that it counts the full turnover between companies (e.g. steel → parts → car).

  • It shows better the size of the production and logistics sector – that's why the OECD uses it in the analysis of supply shocks.
  • Unable to compare debt or surviving standards
  • Not suitable for comparison of debt or surviving standards (includes multiple counting of the same intermediates).
  • It is more than GDP due to the fact that it counts the full turnover between companies (e.g. steel → parts → car).

If the definition of GDP does not subtract indirect consumption, the Polish economy in 2024 weighs about PLN 7.8 trillion ($3.7 trillion) – more than twice as much as the classical gross home product.

How much more would this increase if it added a grey region and unpaid work?

  • Substrate from erstwhile analysis – Global production + taxes (without subtracting indirect consumption)
  • number part of the grey region that the CSO doesn't emulate. The planet Bank, EY & IMF show that the full grey area is around 17% of GDP; the CSO already imputes ~11% → "missing" ~6 % of GDP = 0.06 × 3 640 ÷ 220; in global production it besides needs to be added the missing indirect consumption - +80 billion.
  • Add the value of unpaid work in households. Eurostat time-use survey 2020 gives an equivalent value of 26% of GDP for PL; 0.26 × 3 640 ~ 950 billion PLN (here added value of output – marginal indirect consumption).
  • 4. full (gross + non-observed + homework)

In global dollars (PPP):
PPP 2024 = 2,10 PLN ⇢ ≈ 4,3 trillion Int $

Why + 300 billion alternatively than the full 17% of GDP for the grey economy?

  • The CSO already emulates most of the hidden legal activity (work “on hand”) and any illegal activity (cigarettes, alcohol, prostitution).
  • The external models (Schneider, Medina) give ~17% of GDP combined; in the Polish ESA tables we see that about 11% of GDP has been glued to the authoritative GDP. Thus, ~6% of GDP → + PLN 220 billion of added value + proportionally PLN 80 billion of indirect consumption is missing.

Why ~26% of GDP for unpaid work?

  • EU-27 average from Eurostat TUS2019 = 23 % of GDP.
  • Poland has an average number of hours of free care and cooking (approx. 3 h 40 min per day/person) – converted by the auxiliary rate "average wage of home services" represents 0.25–0.27 GDP.
  • In global production there is almost no intermediate consumption (meal, current included in consumption) – so we mainly add added value.
  • How to read the number of 9 trillion PLN (≈ 4.3 trillion Int $)?

How to read the number of 9 trillion PLN (≈ 4.3 trillion Int $)?

  • This is over 2.5 times the average GDP (PLN 3.64 trillion) and about 410% of GDP in global dollars.
  • It is inactive not net (asset-liability) – alternatively "total marketplace output + non-market output", i.e. the absolute advanced limit of "economic size" if each hr of work and each intermediate mentioned.
  • Uncomfortable to taxation policy: public debt would fall to 24%, but... no 1 in the planet pays taxes on home bread baking.
Read Entire Article