Michał Dworczyk, erstwhile Deputy Minister of Defence, warns that the condition of individual reserves of the Polish Army is much worse than the authoritative reports. "It inactive agrees in Excel, but reality is dramatic," he said in the program "Without doctrine".
“In Excel he agrees, in fact he does not”
Michał Dworczyk, erstwhile Deputy Minister of National Defence, and earlier Euro MPs, hosted the program “Without Doctrine”. The conversation mainly affected the condition of the Polish army's individual reserves, which the politician assessed much harsher than the authoritative rankings suggest. He argued that paper indicators can look decent, but they deficiency real strength. 1 conviction most powerfully reverberated: “It inactive agrees with Excel, but reality is dramatic.”
Reserves and return to training
Former Deputy Chief of the Ministry argued that Poland does not present have reserves to make armed forces in the event of a full-scale conflict. He pointed out that our country was the last east flank country to border Russia or Belarus, which did not reconstruct compulsory military training. In his opinion, the return to universal training is doomed. "This is not a question of whether, but when," he said, pointing out that the decision is only a substance of time.
Ammunition and request scale
Dworzyk besides pointed out the disparity in the production of ammunition. According to the figures cited by him, the home production of artillery missiles increased from about 5 1000 to twenty-five 1000 units per year, while on the front in Ukraine even forty-five 1000 missiles per day were consumed. specified a relationship, as he said, “shows the level of drama” and shows how immense the real needs of the modern battlefield are.
NATO and the nature of allied aid
The politician did not question the value of the alliance, but he reserved that the question of the nature of the support was crucial. He recalled that the United States has unique capabilities specified as satellite recognition, logistics and precise firing. However, he was skeptical of the thought that American soldiers would “kick themselves under Włodawa and Olsztyn” and replace Polish troops in direct defence of the country. He spoke of the war itself without illusions, stating that “no 1 wins this war.”
Conclusions for defence
Dworczyk's diagnosis is part of a wider debate on the readiness of the Polish Army. The expansion of the army makes sense only erstwhile accompanied by a real reserve system, ammunition supplies and trained personnel capable of fast mobilisation. The signal from the conversation is clear: simply expanding the states on paper will not replace the ability to actually make forces. In the face of an uncertain situation beyond the east border, this informing touches the foundation of state security.
Numbers and abilities
For respective years, Poland has been expanding its army and expanding its defence spending, placing itself in terms of the share of military spending in the economy at the forefront of NATO. However, Dworzyk points out that the size and declared budget itself is not everything. Without a strategy of reserves, ammunition supplies and efficient mobilization, even an expanded army remains poorly prepared for the most demanding scenario. This discrimination between "stand on paper" and real combat preparedness is the core of his informing and should guide further decisions.
Source: WP News
